Poster for Discipline and Punish

Discipline and Punish (1979) Parents Guide: Is the book OK for kids?

Age Rating, Sex, Violence & Language

English version of "Surveiller et punir : naissance de la prison"

Adult • 1979 • 333 pages • College Level

4.2
Average rating by Bontent members
Sign up for full access
Age
18+

This foundational work of post-structuralist philosophy explores the evolution of the modern penal system, earning its recommended age due to extremely graphic and clinical descriptions of physical torture and execution. Parents should be aware that while it is an academic text, the opening chapters painstakingly detail bodily dismemberment used as punishment in the 18th century. It is intended for advanced students or adult readers… Sign up for the full guide

Sign up to get 40,000+ Bontent parent guides
Unlock ratings, reviews, recommendations and guides for all content types

Is Discipline and Punish appropriate for kids?

This foundational work of post-structuralist philosophy explores the evolution of the modern penal system, earning its recommended age due to extremely graphic and clinical descriptions of physical torture and execution. Parents should be aware that while it is an academic text… Read more — free account

Content severity in Discipline and Punish

Sex Moderate 3/10
Violence Intense 10/10
Language None 0/10
Substances Mild 2/10
Themes Strong 5/10

What happens in Discipline and Punish, moment by moment

  1. p. 3 ⚔ Violence & Gore 10/10
  2. p. 5 ⚔ Violence & Gore 9/10
  3. p. 12 🍷 Substances 2/10
Unlock all 18 flagged passages — free account →

Sex and nudity in Discipline and Punish

While not a focus, the book discusses the 'sexualization' of children in the context of Victorian power structures and the monitoring of adolescent bodies in schools and prisons. Foucault examines how the 18th-century school system sought to control the 'secret' behaviors of students, specifically targeting masturbation as a focal point of discipline. There is an academic mention of 'sodomy' and other sexual behaviors as legal infractions, but no graphic depictions of sex scenes. The text treats these topics as…

Read more — free account

Violence and gore in Discipline and Punish

The opening pages contain some of the most visceral descriptions of physical torture in non-fiction literature, detailing the 1757 execution of Robert-François Damiens. Foucault describes the tearing of flesh with red-hot pincers, the pouring of lead and boiling oil into wounds, and the unsuccessful attempt to dismember the body using four horses. The clinical detail includes descriptions of the smell of burnt flesh and the screams of the victim. Later chapters deal with the 'gentler' but still psychological…

Read more — free account

Language in Discipline and Punish

The text contains academic and legalistic terminology; there is no profanity or modern vulgarity present. All potentially offensive terms are used within a historical or clinical context regarding crime and punishment. Foucault utilizes complex vocabulary and dense theoretical jargon suited for university-level readers. The translation from French maintains a formal and intellectual tone throughout the 333 pages. There are no instances of slurs or casual swearing. The difficulty level is high, requiring…

Read more — free account

Drugs, alcohol, and smoking in Discipline and Punish

Not a primary theme, though there are brief historical mentions of wine or spirits provided to the condemned before execution to manage pain or maintain consciousness. The text mentions the use of drugs or chemicals in the context of medicalizing the prisoner's body within the carceral system. There are brief references to the 'cabarets' or taverns as sites of lower-class disorder that the police sought to monitor. No scenes of recreational drug use or intoxication are depicted. The focus remains on how the state…

Read more — free account

Mature themes in Discipline and Punish

The book explores heavy philosophical concepts including the 'Panopticon' (total surveillance), the loss of individual agency, and how modern institutions—schools, hospitals, and prisons—use discipline to create 'docile bodies.' Foucault argues that the shift from public execution to private incarceration represents a more insidious form of power rather than a humanitarian advancement. He analyzes how the individual becomes a 'case' to be studied and corrected by experts. The text also delves into the concept of…

Read more — free account

Bontent Member Reviews

Register for free to join the conversation!

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Discipline and Punish appropriate for kids?

Bontent's parent guide suggests Discipline and Punish is best for ages 18+. This foundational work of post-structuralist philosophy explores the evolution of the modern penal system, earning its recommended age due to extremely graphic and clinical descriptions of physical torture and…

What age rating does Discipline and Punish have?

Books don't carry official age ratings. Discipline and Punish is published for a Adult audience, and Bontent's independent parent guide recommends it for ages 18+.

What reading level is Discipline and Punish?

Discipline and Punish is 333 pages and its reading level is College Level. Bontent recommends it for ages 18+.

What is Discipline and Punish about?

This foundational work of post-structuralist philosophy explores the evolution of the modern penal system, earning its recommended age due to extremely graphic and clinical descriptions of physical torture and execution. Parents should be aware that while it is an academic text, the opening chapters painstakingly…

Is there sex or nudity in Discipline and Punish?

While not a focus, the book discusses the 'sexualization' of children in the context of Victorian power structures and the monitoring of adolescent bodies in schools and prisons. Foucault examines how the 18th-century school system sought to control the…

How violent is Discipline and Punish?

The opening pages contain some of the most visceral descriptions of physical torture in non-fiction literature, detailing the 1757 execution of Robert-François Damiens. Foucault describes the tearing of flesh with red-hot pincers, the pouring of lead and…

Is the language in Discipline and Punish appropriate for kids?

The text contains academic and legalistic terminology; there is no profanity or modern vulgarity present. All potentially offensive terms are used within a historical or clinical context regarding crime and punishment. Foucault utilizes complex vocabulary and…

Are drugs, alcohol, or smoking depicted in Discipline and Punish?

Not a primary theme, though there are brief historical mentions of wine or spirits provided to the condemned before execution to manage pain or maintain consciousness. The text mentions the use of drugs or chemicals in the context of medicalizing the…

What mature themes appear in Discipline and Punish?

The book explores heavy philosophical concepts including the 'Panopticon' (total surveillance), the loss of individual agency, and how modern institutions—schools, hospitals, and prisons—use discipline to create 'docile bodies.' Foucault argues that the shift…

Where can I read the full Discipline and Punish parent guide?

Create a free Bontent account to unlock page-level notes, filter by your kids' ages, and save titles to your watchlist.

Sign up for access to 40,000+ parent guides.