Poster for My Evil Twin

My Evil Twin (2021) Parents Guide: Is the book OK for kids?

Age Rating, Sex, Violence & Language

Female criminals are often portrayed as caricatures: Black Widows, Queenpins, Mob Molls, or Femme Fatales. But the real stories are much more fascinating and complex.In Pretty Evil New York author Elizabeth Kerri Mahon takes you on a journey through a rogue’s gallery of some of New York’s most notable female criminals. Drawing on newspaper coverage and other primary sources, this collection of historical true crime stories chronicles eleven women who were media sensations in their day, making headlines across the country decades… Sign up for the full guide

Adult • 2021 • 300 pages • 11th-12th Grade

Age
16+

Pretty Evil New York is a historical true-crime collection detailing the lives of eleven female criminals in New York over a hundred-year period. The book focuses on the intersection of media sensationalism and criminal activity, covering topics ranging from larceny to serial murder and organized crime. It is best suited for older teen and adult readers due to the graphic nature of historical crimes, including detailed descriptions of… Sign up for the full guide

Sign up to get 40,000+ Bontent parent guides
Unlock ratings, reviews, recommendations and guides for all content types

Is My Evil Twin appropriate for kids?

Pretty Evil New York is a historical true-crime collection detailing the lives of eleven female criminals in New York over a hundred-year period. The book focuses on the intersection of media sensationalism and criminal activity, covering topics ranging from larceny to serial… Read more — free account

Content severity in My Evil Twin

Sex Mild 2/10
Violence Strong 7/10
Language Moderate 3/10
Substances Moderate 3/10
Themes Strong 5/10

What happens in My Evil Twin, moment by moment

  1. p. 4 🔥 Mature Themes 2/10
  2. p. 12 ⚔ Violence & Gore 6/10
  3. p. 22 ⚔ Violence & Gore 3/10
Unlock all 23 flagged passages — free account →

Sex and nudity in My Evil Twin

Sexual content is not a focus of the book, though the text occasionally references the motives for crimes which sometimes include infidelity or prostitution. There is no explicit sexual content or graphic descriptions of sexual encounters. Any references are handled as historical context for the personal lives of the figures involved, such as the social perceptions of women like Celia Cooney. These mentions are brief and purely peripheral to the criminal narratives presented. The focus remains on the judicial and…

Read more — free account

Violence and gore in My Evil Twin

Violence is the central theme of this true-crime collection and is depicted with historical detail. The text includes descriptions of murders, physical assaults, the use of firearms, and the methods used by serial killers like Lizzie Halliday. Furthermore, it details state-sanctioned violence, specifically the process of hanging prisoners and the use of the electric chair for Ruth Snyder. Readers encounter graphic accounts of past crimes, such as poisoning and domestic stabbings, that are intended to be factual…

Read more — free account

Language in My Evil Twin

The language in this book is professional and journalistic, consistent with a historical non-fiction work. While it quotes primary source materials from past centuries, it does not rely on gratuitous profanity. Any strong language present is reflective of the era's vernacular or direct quotes from historical news articles, including period-typical insults. It is not considered pervasive or designed to offend a modern reader, but rather to establish the atmosphere of the courtroom or the street. The author…

Read more — free account

Drugs, alcohol, and smoking in My Evil Twin

Substance use is mentioned in the context of the historical environment of the figures profiled, particularly during the Prohibition era. Alcohol consumption is referenced in narratives about speakeasies and the organized crime activities of figures like Stephanie St. Clair. There are no depictions of substance abuse presented as glamorous or encouraged; instead, they are linked to the illegal economies of the time. The text occasionally mentions medicinal poisons or chemical components in the context of murder…

Read more — free account

Mature themes in My Evil Twin

The book explores mature themes, including the psychology of criminality, the death penalty, and the intersection of gender and media perception. It discusses paranoia, greed, mental illness, and the systemic challenges faced by women in the justice system during the 1800s and 1900s. These themes are handled with a focus on historical research rather than exploitation. It serves as a study of how society interacts with and creates 'legends' out of notorious individuals through the lens of tabloid journalism. The…

Read more — free account

Bontent Member Reviews

Register for free to join the conversation!

Frequently Asked Questions

Is My Evil Twin appropriate for kids?

Bontent's parent guide suggests My Evil Twin is best for ages 16+. Pretty Evil New York is a historical true-crime collection detailing the lives of eleven female criminals in New York over a hundred-year period. The book focuses on the intersection of media sensationalism and criminal…

What age rating does My Evil Twin have?

Books don't carry official age ratings. My Evil Twin is shelved by its publisher as Adult, but that's a marketing category, not a content rating — Bontent's own review of what's actually on the page puts it at ages 16+.

What reading level is My Evil Twin?

My Evil Twin is 300 pages and its reading level is 11th-12th Grade. Bontent recommends it for ages 16+.

What is My Evil Twin about?

Pretty Evil New York is a historical true-crime collection detailing the lives of eleven female criminals in New York over a hundred-year period. The book focuses on the intersection of media sensationalism and criminal activity, covering topics ranging from larceny to serial murder and organized crime. It is best…

Is there sex or nudity in My Evil Twin?

Sexual content is not a focus of the book, though the text occasionally references the motives for crimes which sometimes include infidelity or prostitution. There is no explicit sexual content or graphic descriptions of sexual encounters. Any references are…

How violent is My Evil Twin?

Violence is the central theme of this true-crime collection and is depicted with historical detail. The text includes descriptions of murders, physical assaults, the use of firearms, and the methods used by serial killers like Lizzie Halliday. Furthermore, it…

Is the language in My Evil Twin appropriate for kids?

The language in this book is professional and journalistic, consistent with a historical non-fiction work. While it quotes primary source materials from past centuries, it does not rely on gratuitous profanity. Any strong language present is reflective of the…

Are drugs, alcohol, or smoking depicted in My Evil Twin?

Substance use is mentioned in the context of the historical environment of the figures profiled, particularly during the Prohibition era. Alcohol consumption is referenced in narratives about speakeasies and the organized crime activities of figures like…

What mature themes appear in My Evil Twin?

The book explores mature themes, including the psychology of criminality, the death penalty, and the intersection of gender and media perception. It discusses paranoia, greed, mental illness, and the systemic challenges faced by women in the justice system…

Where can I read the full My Evil Twin parent guide?

Create a free Bontent account to unlock page-level notes, filter by your kids' ages, and save titles to your watchlist.

Sign up for access to 40,000+ parent guides.