Poster for City

City (1993) Parents Guide: Is the book OK for kids?

Age Rating, Sex, Violence & Language

[Comment by John Clute][1]: > We know better now, of course. But they still entrance us, the old page-turners from the glory days of American SF, half a century or so ago, when the world was full of futures we were never going to have. In the mid-1940s, when he began to publish the episodes that would be assembled as City in 1952, Clifford Simak, a Minneapolis-based journalist and author, could still carry us away with the dream that cars and pollution and even the great cities of the world – "Huddling Place", the title of one of… Sign up for the full guide

YA • 1993 • 256 pages • Grade 7-10

4.6
Average rating by Bontent members
Sign up for full access
Age
12+

City is a classic philosophical science fiction fix-up novel that explores the 10,000-year evolution of the world after humanity abandons urban centers. It is told from the perspective of sentient Dogs and their loyal robot companion, Jenkins, making it a unique study of sociology and pacifism. Parents should note mild sci-fi violence involving mutant 'Supermen' and ants, as well as heavy existential themes regarding the extinction of… Sign up for the full guide

Sign up to get 40,000+ Bontent parent guides
Unlock ratings, reviews, recommendations and guides for all content types

Is City appropriate for kids?

City is a classic philosophical science fiction fix-up novel that explores the 10,000-year evolution of the world after humanity abandons urban centers. It is told from the perspective of sentient Dogs and their loyal robot companion, Jenkins, making it a unique study of… Read more — free account

Content severity in City

Sex Mild 1/10
Violence Strong 5/10
Language Mild 2/10
Substances Mild 2/10
Themes Moderate 4/10

What happens in City, moment by moment

  1. p. 12 🔥 Mature Themes 2/10
  2. p. 22 🍷 Substances 1/10
  3. p. 44 🔥 Mature Themes 3/10
Unlock all 19 flagged passages — free account →

Sex and nudity in City

Sexual content is virtually non-existent, reflecting the mid-century era in which it was written. There are brief mentions of nuclear families and marriages, but no on-page romance or physical intimacy. The text focuses on the evolution of species through the Webster family line, treating lineage as a matter of historical record rather than romantic interest. References to breeding programs for the Dogs are discussed strictly from a biological and genetic engineering standpoint. Even when discussing the future of…

Read more — free account

Violence and gore in City

Violence is mostly conceptual or large-scale, such as the abandonment of cities or the struggle against the 'Ants.' There are occasional descriptions of hunting or mild skirmishes involving mutant humans and bow-and-arrow combat, but it is never gore-heavy. A notable scene involves a mutant named Joe who shows a cold, detached disregard for life by killing a small creature to satisfy his curiosity. The conflict with the Ants involves the destruction of buildings and the mechanical expansion of a hive mind, which…

Read more — free account

Language in City

Very mild. Occasional uses of 'hell' or 'damn,' but the prose is largely clinical and journalistic in style. In 'Huddling Place,' the tone is formal and academic, reflecting the isolated aristocratic lifestyle of the characters. Later chapters featuring the Dogs use simple, earnest language that avoids profanity entirely. Even the mutant characters, who are portrayed as superior or arrogant, do not engage in vulgarity, preferring intellectual condescension. The overall reading experience is very clean and suitable…

Read more — free account

Drugs, alcohol, and smoking in City

Substance use is minimal, limited to occasional references to characters drinking cider or smoking pipes in a domestic context. In the early chapters, characters like Gramp Stevens are seen enjoying a pipe, which is presented as a traditional, grandfatherly habit. There are scenes where individuals share a drink while discussing serious social matters, but there is no depiction of intoxication or substance abuse. The focus remains on the intellectual and social evolution of the world, and substances are only…

Read more — free account

Mature themes in City

Heavy focus on existentialism, the inevitable decline of human civilization, the ethics of genetic tailoring, and the burden of loneliness felt by the immortal robot Jenkins. The novel functions as a 'fix-up' of several stories, each jumping forward in time to show the slow displacement of man by his own creations and the natural world. There is a recurring sense of loss as humans succumb to agoraphobia and eventually leave Earth entirely. The Dogs grapple with their own mythology, often doubting if 'Man' ever…

Read more — free account

Bontent Member Reviews

Register for free to join the conversation!

Frequently Asked Questions

Is City appropriate for kids?

Bontent's parent guide suggests City is best for ages 12+. City is a classic philosophical science fiction fix-up novel that explores the 10,000-year evolution of the world after humanity abandons urban centers. It is told from the perspective of sentient Dogs and their loyal…

What age rating does City have?

Books don't carry official age ratings. City is shelved by its publisher as YA, but that's a marketing category, not a content rating — Bontent's own review of what's actually on the page puts it at ages 12+.

What reading level is City?

City is 256 pages and its reading level is Grade 7-10. Bontent recommends it for ages 12+.

What is City about?

City is a classic philosophical science fiction fix-up novel that explores the 10,000-year evolution of the world after humanity abandons urban centers. It is told from the perspective of sentient Dogs and their loyal robot companion, Jenkins, making it a unique study of sociology and pacifism. Parents should note…

Is there sex or nudity in City?

Sexual content is virtually non-existent, reflecting the mid-century era in which it was written. There are brief mentions of nuclear families and marriages, but no on-page romance or physical intimacy. The text focuses on the evolution of species through the…

How violent is City?

Violence is mostly conceptual or large-scale, such as the abandonment of cities or the struggle against the 'Ants.' There are occasional descriptions of hunting or mild skirmishes involving mutant humans and bow-and-arrow combat, but it is never gore-heavy. A…

Is the language in City appropriate for kids?

Very mild. Occasional uses of 'hell' or 'damn,' but the prose is largely clinical and journalistic in style. In 'Huddling Place,' the tone is formal and academic, reflecting the isolated aristocratic lifestyle of the characters. Later chapters featuring the…

Are drugs, alcohol, or smoking depicted in City?

Substance use is minimal, limited to occasional references to characters drinking cider or smoking pipes in a domestic context. In the early chapters, characters like Gramp Stevens are seen enjoying a pipe, which is presented as a traditional, grandfatherly…

What mature themes appear in City?

Heavy focus on existentialism, the inevitable decline of human civilization, the ethics of genetic tailoring, and the burden of loneliness felt by the immortal robot Jenkins. The novel functions as a 'fix-up' of several stories, each jumping forward in time…

Where can I read the full City parent guide?

Create a free Bontent account to unlock page-level notes, filter by your kids' ages, and save titles to your watchlist.

Sign up for access to 40,000+ parent guides.